Bottom Line Up Front
- 🏆 Best Overall: Gusto makes benefits feel effortless—health, dental, 401(k), and more, all integrated with payroll.
- 🚀 Best All-in-One Platform: Rippling combines benefits, payroll, IT, and HR in one powerful system.
- 💼 Best for Mid-Market: Zenefits offers enterprise-grade benefits management at SMB-friendly pricing.
Benefits administration used to mean mountains of paperwork, carrier phone trees, and open enrollment chaos. Modern benefits platforms automate enrollment, sync data with carriers automatically, and give employees self-service portals.
But choosing the right platform is tricky. Some are just brokers in disguise (high commissions, limited transparency). Others are software-first but lack carrier relationships. We tested the top contenders based on ease of enrollment, plan variety, and transparent pricing.
Detailed Reviews of the Top Benefits Administration Software
Gusto
Gusto isn't just payroll—it's a full benefits platform. Health insurance, dental, vision, 401(k), FSA, commuter benefits, and more, all managed through one beautiful interface. Enrollment takes minutes, not hours, and everything syncs automatically with carriers.
✅ The Good
- Seamless payroll + benefits integration
- Guided enrollment with smart recommendations
- 401(k) with automatic compliance testing
- Health insurance from major carriers
- FSA/HSA administration included
- Employee self-service portal
- Transparent pricing (no hidden broker fees)
❌ The Not-So-Good
- Limited to businesses with 2+ employees
- Some niche carriers not available
- Benefits advisor is extra ($8/employee/mo)
- No COBRA administration on lower tiers
Via our partner link
Rippling
Rippling is the most ambitious platform on this list: it manages benefits, payroll, IT (laptops, apps, access), and HR compliance in one unified system. When you hire someone, Rippling orders their laptop, enrolls them in benefits, and adds them to payroll—all in one workflow.
✅ The Good
- Unified HR/IT/payroll/benefits platform
- Incredible automation (90-minute onboarding)
- Widest benefits marketplace (health, 401k, etc.)
- Custom workflows for complex setups
- Global payroll and benefits (100+ countries)
- Device management (Mac/PC/phone)
❌ The Not-So-Good
- Expensive (starts at $8/employee/mo base)
- Overkill for small teams (<10 people)
- Steeper learning curve
- Customer support can be slow
Zenefits
Zenefits pioneered the "free HR software, monetize through benefits" model. While it's no longer free, it remains one of the most affordable full-featured HRIS platforms with robust benefits administration, compliance tools, and a massive carrier network.
✅ The Good
- Full HRIS included (PTO, performance, etc.)
- Huge benefits marketplace (100+ carriers)
- ACA compliance tools built-in
- COBRA and FSA administration
- Mobile app for employees
- Integrates with popular payroll providers
❌ The Not-So-Good
- Interface feels dated compared to Gusto
- Customer support quality varies
- Some features locked behind higher tiers
- Confusing pricing structure
Justworks
Justworks is technically a PEO (Professional Employer Organization), not pure software. They become the employer of record, giving you access to Fortune 500-level benefits at small business prices. Great for startups that want top-tier health plans without negotiating with carriers.
✅ The Good
- Access to big-company health plans
- Pre-negotiated rates (often cheaper)
- HR compliance peace of mind (PEO liability)
- Workers' comp included
- 24/7 support with HR experts
- Simple all-in-one pricing
❌ The Not-So-Good
- More expensive than software-only ($49/employee)
- Less flexibility (you're locked into PEO)
- Not ideal if you already have great broker rates
- Can't bring your own carrier
BambooHR
BambooHR is best known as an HRIS (employee database, performance reviews, applicant tracking), but they also offer benefits administration through a broker partnership. It's not as seamless as Gusto or Rippling, but works well if you're already using BambooHR.
✅ The Good
- Best-in-class HRIS features
- Beautiful, intuitive interface
- Strong reporting and analytics
- Employee satisfaction surveys
- Excellent customer support
- ATS and performance management included
❌ The Not-So-Good
- Benefits feel like an afterthought
- No built-in payroll (partner required)
- More expensive than pure benefits platforms
- Smaller carrier network than competitors
Namely
Namely targets mid-market companies (50-500 employees) with a full-featured HRIS that includes benefits, payroll, time tracking, and compliance tools. It's more robust than Gusto but less complex than Workday or ADP Workforce Now.
✅ The Good
- Full-service benefits admin + enrollment
- Dedicated account manager included
- Custom workflows for complex rules
- Social-style employee directory
- Integrated payroll and time tracking
- Strong compliance tools (ACA, COBRA)
❌ The Not-So-Good
- Expensive (best for 50+ employees)
- Implementation takes 4-8 weeks
- Mobile app is clunky
- Reports can be hard to customize
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Gusto | Rippling | Zenefits | Justworks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best For | Most SMBs | Tech/Growth | Mid-Market | Startups (PEO) |
| Starting Price | $40 + $6/mo | $8-12/mo | $8/mo | $49/mo all-in |
| Payroll Included | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes | Add-on | ✓ Yes |
| 401(k) Admin | ✓ Built-in | ✓ Built-in | ✓ Partner | ✓ Included |
| Health Insurance | 20+ carriers | 40+ carriers | 100+ carriers | Pre-negotiated |
| COBRA Admin | Higher tier | ✓ Included | ✓ Included | ✓ Included |
| Ease of Use | Easiest | Moderate | Moderate | Easy |
How to Choose the Right Benefits Platform
1. Understand Your Benefits Strategy
- Competitive benefits? Use Justworks (PEO) for Fortune 500-level plans at small biz prices.
- Basic coverage? Gusto or Zenefits work great and won't break the bank.
- Complex multi-state? Rippling handles regional carriers and compliance nuances.
- 401(k) focus? Gusto's built-in retirement admin is best-in-class.
2. Consider Integration with Existing Systems
If you already use payroll software you love (like ADP or Paychex), adding benefits through Zenefits might make more sense than switching everything to Gusto. Check integration support before committing.
3. Factor in Broker Fees (Hidden Costs)
Traditional brokers earn 3-8% commission on your premiums forever. Gusto and Rippling charge transparent software fees instead. For a team of 20 spending $150k/year on health insurance, that's $4,500-$12,000/year saved.
4. Think About Employee Experience
Benefits enrollment happens once a year, but employees check their coverage, deductibles, and FSA balances regularly. Gusto and Rippling have the cleanest employee portals—Zenefits feels dated by comparison.
5. Plan for Growth
If you're 10 people today but plan to hit 50+ in 2-3 years, avoid tools that don't scale (e.g., Homebase). Rippling and Zenefits grow with you from 5 to 5,000 employees.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need benefits administration software, or can I just work with a broker?
You can use a broker, but modern software like Gusto automates what brokers do manually (enrollment, carrier syncing, compliance tracking) for less money. Plus, you get payroll and HR tools bundled in.
What's the difference between a PEO (like Justworks) and software (like Gusto)?
A PEO becomes your co-employer, giving you access to their benefits and handling compliance risk. Software platforms just provide tools—you remain the employer of record. PEOs are more expensive but offer better plans for very small teams.
Can I offer health insurance if I only have 2 employees?
In most states, yes, but the options are limited and expensive. Gusto requires 2+ W-2 employees; Justworks (PEO) works for companies of any size. Consider QSEHRA (reimbursement) as an alternative.
How hard is it to switch benefits platforms mid-year?
It's doable but annoying. You'll need to re-enroll everyone and coordinate with carriers. Switching at year-end (during open enrollment) is much smoother. Most platforms offer "concierge migration" to help.
What benefits should I offer to compete for talent?
At minimum: health insurance (90%+ employees expect this) and 401(k) matching (even 3% matters). Nice-to-haves: dental, vision, FSA/HSA, commuter benefits, and life/disability insurance.
Ready to Simplify Benefits?
Try Gusto free for 1 month. Payroll + benefits in one platform.
Start Your Free Trial